Rant Thread

Is there anything at all you dislike about the series? Then this is the page to post it! Discuss why you think it's a negativity, or why you disagree. These opinions are of course personal, so don't take any offence if other users don't like the same chars as you do. It's only natural.

This thread will contain spoilers. Please move with caution if you dislike having the books spoiled. And when you write large spoilers, make sure to add them in a spoiler, so the user can choose to see/not see it

Spoiler:

(Major spoiler ahead if you didn't read the Last Hope.)

Spoiler:

They're obviously not as creative as they were in the beginning, no... All the deaths in the final book upset me T.T

Spoiler:

I never cared for Spottedleaf... Anyways, the Erin's just sold out and they jut were writing books every few months to rake in the cash, uncaring of readers opinions... Quality not quantity... DX

Exactly, Snow! I've always wanted quality books rather than a load of bad ones... Honestly, the fact that they're many different people writing too makes me confused. They even managed to mess up by forgetting what colors some of the cats were *facepaw* In one series the cat would be silver, in the second they're brown. Something failed with their plan.

I disliked the fact that ROWANCLAW went from GIRL to BOY!

Yeah, like the said Brambleclaw's eyes were amber while on the cover, they were green...

I know... Wierd.

Or how Heavystep died like two times or three.

Did he? XD I didn't notice weird.

And Rowanclaw switching genders, I was like wow they don't keep track of the cats anymore??

But Snoweh what you said before I totally agree! Lamest way for Firestar to die!! DX<
He defeats Tigerstar! XD yaaay! oops lets just randomly kill him with a what? A branch? That's on fire. Wow great ending to Firestar's epic life, NOT! DX

The last few books were just junk. Failures in comparison to the first two series. It just became garbage after that in my opinion.

And I bet there's loads of other mistakes made throughout the book too xP I noticed they called Stonefur for Stormfur somewhere as well... Or the other way around >.> Can't remember. Many months since I read the books.

The authors obviously found it amusing to kill the leader they'd cherished the last years with a twig...

Yes, very amusing. WHY FIRESTAR? WHY A BRANCH? He's Firestar! Not some random cat that no one cares about! *Sob*

Lol!! I love this discussion... XD

Yeah, stupid way for him to die.

Another error I noticed was how they kept on confusing Mousefur with Mousewhisker or vice versa... Also, how there was so many spelling mistakes and grammer! Was there no freaking editor!?! I wanted to rip my hair out when I read that... DX

Longtail got a tree... Why didn't Firestar get one too? T.T

Agreed, Snow. It became very frustrating to read the book, what with rare mistakes that even I would detect. I'd believe that a professional author would have more common sense. By far, I think Warriors is among some of the weaker books I've read... Honestly. The quanity of the books, as well as the low quality just annoys me so incredibly much x.x

Yeah. Just so many errors, it was killing me! But, I have read a book with more errors. It is a really cheap book from a club called the Pony Club I had when I was like seven. One of the books was called Battlecry Forver but on the title, they spelled it Battlcry Forever... XD (It was a great book though... XD)

lol X3 I was also sad when Rainfur of SkyClan died. I know a lot of people don't like SkyClan but I like Rainfur he was intellegent, thoughtful and kind. Sometimes I wondered if he would have been SkyClan's rightful leader if he had lived. Leafstar is cool but then again so was Rainfur.

I agree with you that Rainfur's cooler than Leafstar. I liked Leafdapple, but not Leafstar... She's not suited to be leader. Rainfur's the best of the warriors, in my opinion. He's among the few names I remember from theSkyClan's destiny super edition xP

Yeah. Leafdapple seemed smart and collected as a warrior but after her leader ceremonie she became to serious. XP