Brambleclaw/star?

WARNING: This thread will probably contain loads of spoilers.

Do you think StarClan made the right choice when making Brambleclaw leader? I certainly don't, but... I want to hear what you think about the case! Bad or good choice?

I'm not sure, I think they did, but if something bad happens to him(you know, DF) then maybe it's not such a good choice.

I thought it was great until his first choice as leader. *Spoiler Ahead*
He chose Squirrelflight as deputy! She is the worst choice of a cat for deputy. He should of chose Brakenfur immediantly because he was Firestar's first choice for deputy until Leadpool butted in... Angry about that! DX

I do know that Graystripe was originally deputy until he was catnapped. Yeah I haven't been reading these a lot lately so I don't know where this has gone. Honestly, Squirrelflight is too hyper to be the deputy. All I have to say.

Yup. She is not very serious and will make stupid choices. I could meet see her being leader... XP

Immature, with other words xP We all agree that Squirrelflight's not the right choice as a deputy, I assume? Although the real question is if Brambleclaw should be the 'star. Honestly, I hated him as a warrior, and I hate him as a leader >.>

I liked him as a plain warrior but when he became deputy, I wished he would be killed before he became leader. He will never be a spec of dust as good as Firestar. Completely a bad choice and picking Squirrelflight as deputy published my hate for him.

Right x3 Personally, I always thought of him as way too much of a gary-sue. Perfect in everything, naturally born leader, great fighting skills, gets what he wants etc. Then the usual attempt at making him look great by adding a dark past, troubled feelings and so on. Just a long recipe on how to make the most boring cat in the world. Problem is, cats often tend to become overly serious when they're made leaders... >.>

Yeah... XP

It would be so funny if they made Leafpool leader or Cloudtail... XD
Most of the Clan is not fit for leadership so most of the Clan... XD

XD I would have loved to see Cloudtail be leader, I wonder how that would work out... o.o
I really wanted Lionblaze to be leader, but really just because he could have sort of filled in for Lionheart. I loved Lionheart! He was cool! X3

They're a bunch of idiots... I want Lionheart and Whitestorm back T.T

Right! TnT

Nooo! Lionheart? Why did you have to die?

If only Rusty never showed up and Whitestorm was electe leader after all the deputies Bluestar picked seemed to kill eachother... XD

Or Rusty was eaten by Yellowfang when she had the chance xP Then we'd all live happily in a perfectly good clan, without a load of kittypets in it. Now that I think about it, Oakheart was killed when fighting Tigerstar or something like that, Redtail was killed by Tigerstar and Stonefur was killed by Tigerstar. Tigerstar really don't like them deputies >.> He'd probably love to kill Brambleclaw too

Well, he wouldn't of killed him on his early deputyship because he is his son. When he "betrayed" Hawkfrost and saved Firestar, then he wanted to kill him probably... XD

He should just die along with Squirellflight so that Lionblaze can be deputy. Who do you think Lionblaze would choose to be his deputy?

I'd rather see Brackenfur or Graystripe as the leader. I'm a supporter of Graystar and his deputy, Brackenfur c: I don't think it would be fair to have an invincible cat as a leader. He'd live forever. He's got to be a prophecy cat already. Then I wish Millie to die, and Graystar to realise Silverstream was his true love, get his filthy kits out of the clan and they live happily ever after! ^.^

The end.

*applause*

Beautiful. As long as Millie is gone I'm probably going to be happy.

Yeah, I hope Millie, Daisy and all of their kits happen to fall of a cliff or have rocks tied to their feet and they walk on the bottom of the lake.... I hate kittypets. Firestar is the only exception but I could of lived without him...

Yeah, I could see Brackenstar with Graystripe as deputy...

Yush, and then Silverstream would kill the useless kittypets just to make up for all the pain it's caused to all us warriors readers and to take revenge on Millie for stealing her love c: Daisy... Well, she's just annoying, isn't she? >.> Guess we should bring this to the rant thread though..?

Opposite of what I think, then :3 I honestly like Graystripe more, although Brackenfur's nice too. However, I'd rather see ThunderClan die than have Bramblestar the leader. *shifty eyes*

I dislike Bramblestar, along with about 9045856423 others lol. He wasn't a good choice.. I'd like to see Graystripe or Brackenfur as deputy, like Silver does. Them kittypets in ThunderClan just annoy me.

You guys remember when ThunderClan and WindClan merged, as well as RiverClan and ShadowClan did? It'd be kinda cool if it stayed like that, I have to admit.

I never liked Firestar, Brambleclaw, OR Squirrelflight.
The true leader for ThunderClan is Graystripe. :/

why did firestar die!?!

bramblrclaw can never be trusted